This article reprinted with permission from the
Winter 2001
issue of Aspects, a publication of the
SIU School of Medicine
Acupuncture: How much medicine can fit on the tip of a needle?
Dr. Terry Arnold takes a scientific spin on an ancient
practice
written by Karen Carlson
photographs by James Hawker
A
70-year-old retired physician with chronic back pain endured
numerous surgeries with little relief. A member of his church in
Macomb, Illinois, who had experienced similar pain told him about an
alternative therapy that had worked wonders for her: acupuncture.
Eager to seek relief from the aching, though not debilitating
pain, the physician decided to give acupuncture a try.
That such an experienced physician would try the technique shows
just how much ground the practice of acupuncture is gaining in the
world of modern medicine.
The benefits of Chinese acupuncture have been documented for
2,000 years, and recent evidence indicates acupuncture may be even
older.
"Something that has been around this long, I knew there had
to be something to it," says Terry Arnold, M.D., assistant
professor in SIU's Department of Family Practice. A physician for
more than 25 years, Dr. Arnold has had an interest in acupuncture
for many years. In 1999, he undertook professional training in
medical acupuncture and has incorporated the therapy into his family
practice in at the SIU Family Practice Center in Quincy, Illinois.
"Acupuncture often will provide relief without the side
effects of pharmaceutical therapies," says Dr. Arnold.
Acupuncture bases its approach on maintaining harmony of the body's
life forces. It is used to treat more than 200 different diseases
and conditions, including stroke, heart attack, asthma, infertility,
addiction withdrawl and chronic fatigue.
"Acupuncture's purpose is to restore the body to its normal
status," says Dr. Arnold, who uses it strictly as an adjunctive
therapy for patients with chronic pain problems, such as back pain,
carpal tunnel or fibromyalgia. He administers acupuncture once or
twice a week, using it as a "last resort" if a patient is
not responding to traditional therapies. Research has shown that
medical acupuncture - acupuncture administered by a physician - is
most beneficial when used in correlation with modern medicine.
While some acupuncturists may extol the spiritual experience of
acupuncture, Dr. Arnold prefers the objective, scientific
perspective of a physician. "Medical acupuncture is a very
well-disciplined approach with extremely rigid parameters of
treatment. Acupuncture is an art, but it has scientific data to
support it."
Before treating with acupuncture, Dr. Arnold educates patients
about it and gives them a thorough physical exam to assess their
likelihood of positive response to the procedure. Then, he designs
an acupuncture plan for patients based on their medical history and
symptoms. Some acupuncturists, he explains, design plans based on a
patient's personality and preferences for things like weather,
flavors and colors. Others examine the tongue as a kind of road map
for internal organs.
The
typical therapy involves 10-30 thin, sterile, stainless steel
acupuncture needles of varying lengths that are inserted into
specific acupuncture points on the body, just millimeters beneath
the skin.
According to acupuncture practitioners, the body contains more
than 400 acupuncture points found in small depressions in the skin
called "gates" where the body's energy channels, or
meridians, come closest to the surface. Individual parts of the body
such as the hand or the ear contain additional sets of hundreds of
points. Acupuncture "opens the gates" of the body to
mobilize and balance energies by stimulating circulation of the
body's animating forces and releasing one of the body's natural
hormones, endorphins, to restore and regulate organ function.
The needles are left in place for 30-45 minutes, with the
practitioner manually manipulating them to direct the body's energy
and - in Dr. Arnold's use - affect the perception of pain.
"In an acute injury, such as a muscle sprain, there is too
much energy, and that is causing inflammation," says Dr.
Arnold, who cools the needles with alcohol to draw out the excess
energy. Chronic pain signals a lack of energy, so needles are warmed
with heat lamps or electricity to provide more energy.
A typical session takes quite a bit of time: 60-90 minutes. To
relax the patient, Dr. Arnold darkens the room and plays traditional
Chinese music for sleeping. Because the needles barely poke the
surface of the skin, the procedure is not painful, nor are there any
side effects when the procedure is administered properly. Patients
find it a relaxing experience, sometimes even drifting off to sleep.
"Acupuncture is a controlling measure, not a cure,"
says Dr. Arnold, who recommends a minimum of three to four
treatments to see any significant reduction in pain. He explains the
cumulative effect. "With each subsequent treatment, the effects
become longer lasting to the point that ideally a patient could go
several weeks or months between treatments." If patients fail
to experience significant relief, Dr. Arnold is not shy about
suggesting they abandon the procedure, as did the 70-year-old
physician with back pain. "But he was very open to the
procedure and he was glad he tried it," says Dr. Arnold.
Along
with standard acupuncture, Dr. Arnold sometimes connects the needles
to an electrical device to send a painless electrical pulse to the
targeted areas. Cupping is another acupuncture procedure he uses to
augment patient response. In this procedure, Chinese fire cups of
different sizes are warmed and placed on the skin to increase the
blood flow.
"This is not a mental or spiritual response," he
stresses. "There is no question that there is a physical
component to acupuncture involving the body's release of
endorphins."
Though acupuncture has been used by the Chinese continuously for
two millennia, the western world has opened up to it as a legitimate
medical practice only over the past two decades. In 1994, the FDA
upgraded the "experimental" status of acupuncture needles,
approving them for medical use. The Illinois Acupuncture Practice
Act (1997) requires practicing acupuncturists to obtain physician
referrals. In 1999, the World Heath Organization published
guidelines for basic training and safety in acupuncture, considering
acupuncture an appropriate tool to treat bodily infections,
musculoskeletal pain, internal and neurological diseases,
reproductive problems and mental disorders, among others.
Dr. Arnold definitely sees a future for medical acupuncture. As
an associate program director of the SIU Quincy Family Practice
Residency Program, he has created opportunities for students and
residents to observe the procedure. "It's very worthwhile for
physicians to know a little bit about this process and realize that
it is a tool they can use - maybe not in their own offices - but
they can refer patients to a resource in their community."
As this centuries-old practice continues to grow in popularity,
time will tell how much medicine can fit on the tip of a needle.
|