Reading, Cheating, and 'Rithmetic
by Tucker Carlson
Part 1
[1] It's a tenth-grader's dream: Your teacher catches you cheating, and your
parents take your side. That's exactly what happened last December to a
group of sophomores at Piper High School in Piper, Kan. Teacher Christine
Pelton had assigned her students a semester-long biology project. When the
kids turned in their papers, Pelton found that almost a quarter of them
(28 out of 118) had been plagiarized. And not only plagiarized, but
plagiarized poorly. According to Pelton, entire sections of the papers were
identical, copied from the same Internet websites.
[2] She had already warned her students about cheating and its consequences.
Each of the 28 offenders received a zero on the assignment, and a failing
grade in the class. But only temporarily.
[3] Soon, parents of the 28 complained to the local school board, refusing to
believe their child had cheated. The penalty, all the parents said, was too
harsh. And the school board agreed: Pelton was instructed to give the
cheaters partial credit for their work. The cheaters were thrilled. The
next day, Pelton told the Kansas City Star, "I went to my class and tried
to teach the kids, but they were whooping and hollering and saying, 'We
don't have to listen to you anymore.'"
[4] Her authority gone, Pelton did the only thing she could: She immediately
quit in protest. Most teachers don't. At many high schools and
universities, cheating is routine, teacher apathy the norm. A series of
studies by Rutgers University professor Donald McCabe found that on most
campuses, more than 75 percent of students cheat. And why wouldn't they?
According to McCabe, a 1999 survey of 1000 faculty members at 21 colleges
found that "one-third of those who were aware of student cheating in their
course in the last two years did nothing to address it." In other words,
there are far more plagiarists on campus than there are Christine Peltons.
[5] The Internet has made plagiarism particularly tempting. Dozens of websites
with names like school-sucks.com offer prewritten term papers for sale at
bargain prices. Need 5000 words on Feminist Consciousness and Gender Roles
in Pre-Columbian Latin America? It's only a mouse click away.
[6] On the other hand, so is discovery. Technology has made catching cheaters
just as easy. Several websites offer software that automatically compares
the text of a student's work against a database of thousands of term papers
and published books and articles. If there's a match, there's likely
plagiarism. |